The Strange Commonality Between Sedevacantists and the IRS
First I want to talk about a fascinating book by Pete Hendrickson called Cracking the Code: The Fascinating Truth About Taxation in America, which explains United States federal income tax law.
The truth is the majority of Americans don't have any obligation under law to pay federal income tax. Such a law directly taxing the wages of all Americans would be unconstitutional, hence the gnashing of teeth and strange history of tax protests here.
As I'm sure most people are aware, just about all respectable Americans pay income tax anyway. What happened? The IRS has spent many decades undertaking a disinformation campaign. What they have done is teach normal Americans that tax law is written in everyday English. Pete Hendrickson gives a simplified example of this on page 57 of my copy:
As he goes on to explain in the book, words like "income", "wages", "employer" and more are legal terms in USA tax law. These legal terms have specific, extremely limited meanings, and their definitions are stated in disparate parts of the body of tax law. To reuse the analogy, "fruit" in tax law only refers to apples, pears and oranges.
If these terms had their everyday meaning in the tax law, the federal income tax would be unconstitutional. This is why there is nothing inconsistent with the US Supreme Court upholding the federal income tax on multiple occasions.
I'm not going to explain tax law to you. Read the book. If you're an American, it could save you a lot of money. Even if you're not, this book is a great layman's primer on the way law works. It reveals one of the most amazing feats of wizardry in modern times, and it also teaches us an important principle of law in civilized countries that is often forgotten: you must define your terms and reduce ambiquity as much as possible, ideally to zero.
Now let's go back to the Sedevacantists, specifically those that would attempt to argue a Pope is invalid post hoc by citing snippets from Canon Law.
In any such argument, you must demonstrate the terms mean what you claim they mean. Let's go to the example of Canon 188.4, which states in Latin, then English paraphrase:
All of these terms must be defined. In this particular case, the most crucial word is in English "defection" and Latin "defecerit". It must be demonstrated that these terms encompass--in their originally intended legal meaning--ratifying, upholding or teaching post Vatican II doctrine, and this must be demonstrated beyond a shadow of a doubt if you are trying to be rigorous in proving the legal case that the Pope is not the Pope.
Instead, what most Sedevacantists do is insist defect means what we would think it means in everyday language. Because Vatican II and the ensuing Popes do so many things that on first glance appear questionable, possibly even heretical, in the context of the Roman church's entire history, that means they defected from the faith in the legal sense. The legal part is key, that's what I'm questioning.
I'm not here to argue post-V2 Popes aren't satanic anti-popes. It's possible that Canon 188.4 applies to them, but this is never demonstrated in a legally rigorous way. To my mind, the relevant legal definitions would either be in Canon Law itself or a separate Catholic legal dictionary, and that's the level of proof we need before feeling certain any such argument is true.
If such proof does not exist, that would mean the Sedevacantists are running the same racket the IRS runs to defraud millions of Americans out of billions of dollars. Don't be a sap.
The truth is the majority of Americans don't have any obligation under law to pay federal income tax. Such a law directly taxing the wages of all Americans would be unconstitutional, hence the gnashing of teeth and strange history of tax protests here.
As I'm sure most people are aware, just about all respectable Americans pay income tax anyway. What happened? The IRS has spent many decades undertaking a disinformation campaign. What they have done is teach normal Americans that tax law is written in everyday English. Pete Hendrickson gives a simplified example of this on page 57 of my copy:
If language such as, "For purposes of this paragraph, the term "Fruit" includes apples, pears, and oranges," is used, it can only be understood as restricting the definition to those things listed, or no definition would be required
As he goes on to explain in the book, words like "income", "wages", "employer" and more are legal terms in USA tax law. These legal terms have specific, extremely limited meanings, and their definitions are stated in disparate parts of the body of tax law. To reuse the analogy, "fruit" in tax law only refers to apples, pears and oranges.
If these terms had their everyday meaning in the tax law, the federal income tax would be unconstitutional. This is why there is nothing inconsistent with the US Supreme Court upholding the federal income tax on multiple occasions.
I'm not going to explain tax law to you. Read the book. If you're an American, it could save you a lot of money. Even if you're not, this book is a great layman's primer on the way law works. It reveals one of the most amazing feats of wizardry in modern times, and it also teaches us an important principle of law in civilized countries that is often forgotten: you must define your terms and reduce ambiquity as much as possible, ideally to zero.
Now let's go back to the Sedevacantists, specifically those that would attempt to argue a Pope is invalid post hoc by citing snippets from Canon Law.
In any such argument, you must demonstrate the terms mean what you claim they mean. Let's go to the example of Canon 188.4, which states in Latin, then English paraphrase:
Ob tacitam renuntiationem ab ipso iure admissam quaelibet officia vacant ipso facto et sine ulla declaratione, si clericus: ...4 A fide catholica publice defecerit.
No one, unless he profess the Catholic Faith, can hold any office — that is, lay valid claim to authority in the Catholic Church. For the faithful to know this fact and refuse obedience, no formality is required: neither sentence passed by a court nor any other official pronouncement, nor a formally expressed resignation accepted by some official. Defection itself from the Catholic Faith constitutes resignation.
Source: http://www.traditionalmass.org/articles/article.php?id=12&catname=10
All of these terms must be defined. In this particular case, the most crucial word is in English "defection" and Latin "defecerit". It must be demonstrated that these terms encompass--in their originally intended legal meaning--ratifying, upholding or teaching post Vatican II doctrine, and this must be demonstrated beyond a shadow of a doubt if you are trying to be rigorous in proving the legal case that the Pope is not the Pope.
Instead, what most Sedevacantists do is insist defect means what we would think it means in everyday language. Because Vatican II and the ensuing Popes do so many things that on first glance appear questionable, possibly even heretical, in the context of the Roman church's entire history, that means they defected from the faith in the legal sense. The legal part is key, that's what I'm questioning.
I'm not here to argue post-V2 Popes aren't satanic anti-popes. It's possible that Canon 188.4 applies to them, but this is never demonstrated in a legally rigorous way. To my mind, the relevant legal definitions would either be in Canon Law itself or a separate Catholic legal dictionary, and that's the level of proof we need before feeling certain any such argument is true.
If such proof does not exist, that would mean the Sedevacantists are running the same racket the IRS runs to defraud millions of Americans out of billions of dollars. Don't be a sap.
Comments
Post a Comment